TDmonthly Magazine!
January 2009 | Vol. VIII - No. 1


Tools: Print RSS X (Twitter) Facebook Reddit


Good Co./Bad Co.: Who’s Fair to Specialty?

Retailers Tell Who They Did and Didn’t Like in 2008


In late 2008, TDmonthly Magazine asked 52 specialty retailers to share their preferences for vendors. Which companies can they not live without? And which ones incite groans from the stockroom? Melissa & Doug walked away with the gold for being named a favorite by nearly half of the retailers surveyed. Toysmith and International Playthings were next in line in terms of favorable suppliers, while LEGO and Ganz headlined for disappointment. Take a look at the chart below to see how many retailers said they consider the following manufacturers their favorite or least favorite. Vendors had to have at least two favorable or two unfavorable mentions to be included. See also “Good Co./Bad Co.: Feel the Love” and “Good Co./Bad Co.: Vendors That Bring You Down."

(No manufacturer paid to be included in this article. All products listed were chosen by editorial staff without regard to the company's relationship with ToyDirectory.com/TDmonthly Magazine.)




Free toy industry news by email

New toys, trends and industry news from The ToyDirectory Intelligence Report.

Subscribe free

Free to join on Substack; a paid plan is optional. Unsubscribe anytime.





Julie L. JonesWriter's Bio: Julie L. Jones has written articles for both newspapers and magazines. Before joining the staff of TDmonthly Magazine, she worked as a communications writer and provided editorial support for a market research company. Read more articles by this author


THIS BANNER IS AN AD:


This Month's Features



Back to TDmonthly's front page

Advertise on TDmonthly


Related Products

Love Super TOOB®
By SAFARI LTD.®
» More Information

TinkerTar Tiger Guitar
By BUFFALO GAMES INC.
» More Information

Fisher-Price 4-in-1 Cuddle & Crawl Duck
By FISHER-PRICE INC.
» More Information


Related Articles
·Who's Hiring in the Toy Industry: 52 Open Jobs at Mattel, Hasbro, Spin Master, LEGO, MGA and Funko
(11/1/2026)
·Toys"R"Us 160+ U.S. Stores, Grand Central Date: Toy News 11/13/2026
(11/1/2026)
·LEGO SMART Play in 2026: What Ten Months Taught Retailers and Toy Manufacturers
(11/1/2026)
·Why Letting AI Do Your Homework Could Hurt Your Brainpower: An 11-Year-Old's Guide to Better Reading
(12/1/2024)
·Fans Of Wicked And Ariana Grande Have A Variety Of Themed Merchandise To Choose From
(12/1/2024)
·How Did Ariana Grande Respond To The Backlash About Her Voice For The Role Of Glinda
(12/1/2024)


Also See
·Holiday 2026 LEGO Sets: Godzilla, Buddy the Elf, Holiday House
(11/1/2026)
·Best Toys for 4-Year-Olds 2026: 7 Picks for Pretend Play, Building
(10/4/2026)
·Advent Calendars Under $40 (2026): 9 Non-LEGO Picks, Bluey to Clue
(10/4/2026)
·Best Toys Under $30 (2026)
(10/4/2026)
·Screen-Free Tween Gifts Under $40: 10 Picks They'll Use (2026)
(10/4/2026)
·Kids' Advent Calendars 2026 by Age: Play-Doh, HABA, Hot Wheels
(10/4/2026)
















Advertisement: