Why Did Fans React So Negatively To Ariana Grande's Casting As Glinda

By Laura N. Larsson
December 2024

When Ariana Grande was cast as Glinda in the upcoming Wicked film adaptation, the announcement was met with mixed reactions from fans. Several factors contributed to the skepticism surrounding her casting:

Pop Star Image

Many fans primarily associate Grande with her successful pop music career, featuring hits like "7 Rings" and "Side to Side." This association led to doubts about her ability to embody a beloved musical theater character such as Glinda.

Lack of Awareness of Theater Background

Some fans were unaware of Grande's roots in musical theater, including her Broadway debut in 2008's 13: The Musical. This limited awareness contributed to skepticism regarding her suitability for the role.

Long-Awaited Adaptation

Fans had been anticipating a Wicked movie adaptation for nearly two decades. The prolonged wait heightened expectations and made fans particularly protective of casting decisions.

Perceived Stunt Casting

There were concerns that Grande's casting was a move to leverage her star power rather than prioritize theatrical ability, leading to fears that her pop star status might overshadow the character of Glinda.

High Stakes and Fan Investment

Wicked holds a special place in many fans' hearts, resulting in intense scrutiny of casting choices. The pressure to meet fan expectations for such a cherished musical contributed to the initial backlash.

Addressing these concerns, Grande acknowledged the skepticism, stating, "Going off of 'Side to Side,' I probably would've said the same thing. I probably would've said, 'Why the f***? Kill me. I've waited 20 years for this.... Kill me.'" She understood the fans' perspective, especially those familiar only with her pop music, and recognized the challenge of reshaping public perception of her abilities.

Screen Rant

Despite the initial doubts, Grande's dedication to the role and her musical theater background have since alleviated many fans' concerns, building anticipation for her portrayal of Glinda.